The Self-Doubt Loop: Why You Don’t Trust Yourself

Do you struggle to make decisions? Do you wonder why you don’t trust yourself?

You might be capable, responsible, and thoughtful. And yet, when you have to make a decision, you may feel anxious, struggle to choose, defer to others, or second-guess yourself even after extensive research.

I know this feeling well.

For a long time, I thought I was simply indecisive. But I’ve come to realize that struggling to make decisions isn’t always about not knowing what to do. Sometimes, it’s about not trusting our own judgment. And that lack of self-trust may have roots in experiences that go back much further than we realize.

When Your Experience Is Repeatedly Dismissed

Children depend on adults to help them make sense of their experiences.

When something hurts, frightens, disappoints, or confuses them, they naturally look to their caregivers for help understanding what happened.

Ideally, a parent helps the child put words to their experience:

That really hurt.
You were scared when that happened.
I can understand why you’re upset.

The parent doesn’t necessarily have to agree with everything the child thinks. But they acknowledge that the child’s internal experience is real.

Some parents may struggle with this. A child’s feelings can feel inconvenient, uncomfortable, dramatic, or even threatening. Instead of helping the child understand what they’re experiencing, the parent may minimize or dismiss it.

You’re fine.
You’re too sensitive.
It didn’t happen like that.

vitaly gariev bskipa4afoy unsplash (2)
Source: Vitaly Gariev | Unsplash

Now the child is receiving two different messages. Inside, something tells them, Something doesn’t feel right. But the adult they depend on says, There’s nothing wrong.

When this happens repeatedly, the child may begin to wonder: Maybe I’m wrong.

Being told that they’re too sensitive or overreacting can deepen that doubt. Instead of simply experiencing their feelings, they begin questioning whether those feelings are reasonable in the first place.

When You Learn to Doubt Your Own Judgment

For a child, the adult usually carries more authority. They’re older, they have more power, and they’re assumed to understand the world better.

So when your experience conflicts with what an adult tells you is true, whose version do you trust?

Instead of thinking, They may be wrong about what I’m experiencing, a child may learn to think, I must be missing something.

Over time, questioning yourself in individual situations can turn into something bigger: you begin to believe you can’t trust your own judgment.

You Begin Looking Outside Yourself for Reassurance

Once you begin doubting your own judgment, you may start looking to others for reassurance.

You might ask someone else what they think. You might explain the situation to a friend and wait to hear whether they agree with you.

christina wocintechchat com m ef7hn40wbaq unsplash
Source: Christina @wocintechchat.com | Unsplash

And reassurance works—at least temporarily. Someone agrees with you, and the uncertainty settles.

But there’s a problem.

If we repeatedly need someone else to reassure us before we can trust ourselves, we may unintentionally reinforce the belief: I can’t trust myself to make decisions unless someone else agrees with me.

And people won’t always agree with us.

We all bring different experiences, values, and perspectives to the same situation. Someone seeing things differently doesn’t necessarily mean our interpretation is wrong. But when we already doubt ourselves, disagreement can feel like evidence that it is.

So we begin questioning ourselves again and looking for more reassurance.

And that’s how the self-doubt loop can continue:

You doubt yourself → you seek reassurance → someone agrees and you feel better temporarily → someone disagrees and you question yourself again → you seek more reassurance.

What feels like a solution to self-doubt can sometimes keep it going.

When Someone Else’s Certainty Feels Like Relief

I’ve also started to wonder how this pattern can shape the people we become close to.

When you don’t fully trust yourself, someone who seems certain of themselves can feel incredibly reassuring.

A person who is confident, decisive, and comfortable taking the lead may make life feel easier. If decisions make you anxious, having someone say, This is what we should do, can feel like a relief.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with that. We all have different strengths, and sometimes one person genuinely enjoys making decisions more than the other.

But the dynamic can become unhealthy when their confidence begins to carry more weight than your own judgment.

You may defer to them even when something doesn’t feel right.

And suddenly, the pattern that began much earlier in life is playing out again.

Something inside you says, This doesn’t feel right.

Someone else says, There’s nothing wrong.

And once again, you wonder whether you should trust yourself.

ummano dias ezqvznal4hc unsplash
Source: Ummano Dias | Unsplash

Before You Go…

If you’ve spent much of your life questioning yourself, it may seem as though self-doubt is simply part of who you are. But sometimes self-doubt is something we learn.

When our feelings and perceptions are repeatedly questioned, we may learn to give other people’s interpretations more weight than our own. Then we look outside ourselves for reassurance, which can make it even harder to trust ourselves without it.

Understanding the self-doubt loop doesn’t mean you’ll suddenly stop second-guessing yourself.

But it helps to remember:

Feeling uncertain doesn’t necessarily mean you can’t trust your own judgment. And someone else seeing things differently doesn’t necessarily mean you’re wrong.

Become curious about why you don’t trust yourself in the first place. Then, little by little, begin listening to your own voice again—especially when it comes to your preferences, needs, feelings, and what feels right for you.

Understanding how self-doubt develops is an important first step. But learning to trust yourself again takes practice. In Why You Second-Guess Everything—and How to Rebuild Self-Trust, I explore how you can begin breaking the habit of second-guessing yourself and build greater confidence in your own judgment.

olive leaf icon on transparent background

Enjoy articles about relationships, emotional healing, and parenting? Get the latest from Becoming Curious delivered to your inbox.

This field is required.

Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your privacy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top